Carly Kimball, columnist for the popular magazine Chit–Chat Weekly, is going undercover to reveal the truth behind Madame Evangeline and 1Night Stand. She'll infiltrate the Grand Turk Castillo hotel and resort for her tell–all article. But Carly is in for an even bigger shock when she comes in contact with a man from her past, Quinn Alfasi, who she shared one passionate night with back in college.

Quinn never thought he'd see Carly again, and now six years later she's come back into his life. He'll do whatever he has to in order to expose her as a liar and a fraud. But then his best friend Woody shows an interest. Quinn won't allow her to fall for Woody's charms even if he has to team up with his Lothario best friend to claim Carly as his own.